How to choose a Magento agency

Posted by Sarah Willcocks, CEO

Why is choosing the right Magento Solution Partner so important?

Magento is one of the most popular eCommerce platforms available today, fuelled largely because of the richness of its functionality and its “open source” nature. There are over 300,000 merchants live on Magento and growing. In addition, Magento is investing heavily in ensuring that Magento 2 remains at the forefront of omnichannel retailing worldwide.  This popularity, however, means that many web developers and companies have adopted the Magento platform without investing in the proper planning, organisation and support that eCommerce software can require.

Because of its “open source” nature, anybody can download it and have a go.  As a result, many merchants end up commissioning websites on the “cheap and cheerful” Magento bandwagon, only to find that they can’t get their projects delivered in a timely manner and when their websites are live, the problems begin. “It’s easy to build a website if you don’t have to support it.” You may then find yourself without the appropriate Magento resources and expertise, and cut off from the fast-evolving world of eCommerce.

Many Magento websites are developed in haste without consideration for the following:

– performance and scaleability
– support and maintenance service (with ongoing handholding)
– professional development standards (e.g. documentation, release procedures, etc.)
– long-term attention to client’s needs for flexibility and ease of maintenance
– proper study of Magento systems design, architecture and best practice
– implementation of security guidelines for cardholder data protection

It is crucial therefore that merchants take into account the following when choosing an agency to execute their Magento eCommerce project. This article will help you make your needs more concrete and show you how to go about choosing an appropriate agency to meet them.

1. First, be clear about what you want

Write it down and be specific. If you don’t know what you want, then you won’t know when you’ve got it. If you are unsure what you want/need, look at your most successful competitor’s website and use the features on their site as a reference. For example, how many ways do you want to allow your customers to pay? Should they be able to add gift messages? Do you want to accept orders from outside the UK? And so on.

Also, think through your list of requirements and how you might want to manage them within your business, i.e. how much time do you have as a business to devote to managing this part of the site.

A simple way to do this is to write down what elements (& moving parts) that you’d like on each material page of the website. Then, write down the processes for fulfilling orders and delivering customer service.

Incidentally, unless you are an eCommerce expert, it’s very difficult to understand what is happening behind the scenes of a page on a website because there are so many dynamic elements, business rules, logic and algorithms, as well as general website parameters.

2. Set a (rough) budget

Set a budget that is appropriate for your anticipated activity & sales. It would be ridiculous to spend £10k on a website that does £10m per annum or £50k where your aspiration is £100k of sales. If you have no idea of what commissioning a new site costs, phone a few different agencies and ask them what their average project price is for a new eCommerce website. This should give you a few pointers. At Screen Pages, we try to understand a client’s budgetary comfort range quite early on as this helps us to make better recommendations when suggesting solutions.

As a guide, our clients spend between 2% and 5% of their online revenues on eCommerce development and operations (excluding marketing costs). This obviously excludes initial capital costs which are linked (in our case) to the amount of time that goes into the project. At Screen Pages, fully managed design and build projects can take 100-200 days, depending on the functional scope of the project.  We know this because we have successfully delivered over 300 websites since 2000.

3. Choose a shortlist of agencies to talk to and check them out

Once you have your requirements and your budget outlined, do your research and look for an agency that has experience of delivering projects of a similar size and nature for businesses similar to yours.  Get them to come in and present.  Meet their people, ask to visit their premises.  Find out who their clients are and how long they have been clients.  Keep your shortlist short (we recommend about 3 agencies or it will soon become a full time job) and ask them all the same questions so you can compare apples with apples.  Get them to tell you what their company values are as its important that you choose an agency with values that complement yours. Things will not always go to plan so make sure you choose an partner that you feel comfortable with.

4. Find out who the project team will be

Many disciplines are involved in putting together an eCommerce website and chances are that the person you’re dealing with won’t be involved in its delivery. You should take pains to understand the project team and the different roles involved.

There’ll be an Account Manager who lead any commercial and marketing issues; a Project Manager who’ll own day-to-day operational and functional delivery, managing both client-side resources as well as internal agency staff; a Creative/Design Lead who’ll provide mock-ups of what you’ll be getting; QA/Testing staff who should make sure you are getting an error-free, quality product which won’t waste all your time spotting problems that should have been cleared up before it came to you.

You also need to arrive at an understanding of how the work will be managed day-to-day, including deadlines, key milestones, sign off stages etc. Once you’re clear about who’s involved, you should be seeking to understand what relevant experience they have and how much involvement they will have on your project.

On the other side of the fence, understand that you will need your own properly resourced, internal project team and Project Manager as well with clearly defined roles and responsibilities. If your internal effort is not clear, this should be discussed and agreed with the agency. In our experience, lack of client testing is the biggest risk to project success – especially where there is integration with back offices for order processing or bespoke, custom functionality.

The second biggest client-side challenge is preparation of data. Tens of products can be reasonably managed manually. But when it comes to many thousands with lots of inter-relating data (variants and attributes) associated with each, getting the data import process right is non-trivial and will probably involve several iterations.

5. Work out how to know you are getting what you are paying for

You will only want to pay for work done completely and properly so you will need to make sure there’s a water-tight definition of the scope of work. A good agency that knows what they are doing will generally price on the amount of time spent on your project and that time is a direct reflection of the functionality required and promised, so it’s best to be clear up front!

Screen Pages’ method for doing this is to prepare and share rather a large spreadsheet that contains every task and “function point”, with an associated time and cost. Not only is this transparent, but it is reasonably accurate. It also includes allocation for more intangible deliverables such as quality assurance & acceptance testing.

You might also consider how mistakes and omissions are handled. Given the fact that you speak “retail” language and we speak “agency”, some of the detail can be lost in translation or quite simply overlooked. Find out what happens in those cases.

Later, we produce detailed mock-ups of all the material pages on your website (not just the home page). Coupled with this, you’ll be presented with a detailed functional specification which explains how every element on every page gets there and is managed.

In our world, you should ask questions on all this until you’re happy you are going to get what you want.  We ask that all designs and specifications are approved and signed off, prior to any development work starting.

6. Is it cheap?

Unfortunately, too many are seduced by an attractive headline price (usually a compelling round number). This is quite wrong: it’s not about the price or day rate – it’s about the amount of time involved. An accurate assessment of the effort involved is what matters, multiplied by the day rate.

You may be aghast at day rates north of £400, but the differential usually covers the overheads of running a professional, well-run business with well trained staff and experienced management.

Think about the kind of service you want/expect as well as the kind of service you need. There is a difference and you pay for what you get. Whether it’s advice, warranties, turnaround times, quality or account management – it all comes with a value.

7. How big & established is the Magento agency?

Granted size doesn’t matter, provided your agency can handle the demands of the new clients it takes on and the ongoing support and update commitments of its existing clients. You should look for critical mass: 1-2 Magento developers will not cut the mustard. You might get what you want on the initial development project, but when they start work on somebody else’s project, how can you ensure you get the service or support you need. An agency with only a few developers will not be able to cope.

Experience counts for a lot, especially with Magento which has over 2 million lines of code. This will soon be all yours and in the tender care of your agency in this open source world. How many years has your agency been working with Magento and how many sites have they built or taken on? Are their developers trained on Magento 2?  How do you know?  How have they been trained?  Are their Project Managers Certified Solution Specialists? Why not?

Of course, there is an obvious third party verification here: Magento itself. Magento operates a formal partnership programme with a system of certification. To qualify for partnership – a formal agreement – a partner must have conducted a certain number of Magento implementations and have a number of “certified” developers, which means they’ve had to sit an exam and the agency would have had to invest in their training.

You can check Screen Pages’s partner credentials on the Magento website.

8. What happens after it’s built?

Building websites is the easiest thing we do. The hardest thing is supporting & extending them. After an eCommerce website is made live, that’s when the whole question of service and support kicks in. It’s fair to say there are always a few issues and niggles that nobody spots, let alone the snags that come up as you manage products, prices, promotions, content & data on your site on a daily basis.

You need a well organised, experienced and professional agency to deliver this with processes for handling support, and with the right amount of manpower & management. Make sure your agency has a proper agreement with structured, documented processes for support, maintenance, problem resolution, warranties etc. Check this is written down in their contract. A sensible and embracing agreement is a good sign of a professional outfit.

Ask how many support questions are asked each month and how many are resolved.  Ask how they are prioritised and how quickly issues are dealt with.

At Screen Pages, under our standard agreement, we offer a 30 day warranty on all issues after the site is made live and an unlimited warranty on any issue we’ve introduced.

9. What other services does the agency provide?

This question is a double-edged sword. You may feel it’s convenient to have your marketing, SEO, affiliate management, etc. all under one roof. Or you may feel that you want a specialist rather than a jack-of-all-trades.

Our view is that it is much better to pick best-of-breed agencies for each service you need. How can you expect in-depth service/expertise/back up if there’s only 1-2 people in each discipline?

We have taken the approach that it’s better to work with experts – we have established relationships with consultants and agencies whose services are “appropriate” for our kinds of clients.

An important exception to this is hosting. This can be a challenge with Magento; a few Google searches will reveal the need for careful consideration of its configuration, performance and optimisation. It’s unlikely that you will know what to ask for or even comprehend what you’ve been told about cacheing, secure FTP, PHP ini files, MySQL etc. Let us take care of all that for you. We have learned the hard way how to optimise our Magento websites and make them work fast. Here’s how we host Magento websites.

10. Take references

This is obvious, but incredibly often overlooked. Here’s some of our eCommerce clients.

11. Check out their financials

Again, it goes without saying, but take a look at their accounts and understand where an agency’s business comes from and its profitability.

Make an enquiry

Email opt in (optional)

10 + 7 =

For information on how we process the data that you give us, please see our privacy policy.

Contact us

4 The Courtyard, Wisley Lane, Surrey, GU23 6QL


Connect with us

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Sign Up To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest e-commerce & Magento news from Screen Pages.

For information on how we process the data that you give us, please see our privacy policy.

You have Successfully Subscribed!